Originally Posted by SoxFanCPA
So if he tags up, he can only score if the bases were loaded. No ****ing way.
Well, letting umpires speculate on what would have happened if the right call was made, creates a slippery slope. Any manager can then argue otherwise, because now we're talking about a hypothetical situation. So your way can cause all types of chaos.
My way, there is a set rule which only allows the minimum benefit to the team that gets a called overturned. No arguments.